The Pantry

Make your own blends

When you cook by the rules in The Approach, spice is doing most of the lifting. Store-bought blends hide salt, sugar, anti-caking agents, and sometimes things I avoid on purpose. Mixing your own takes five minutes and puts you back in charge of the label.

Glass spice jars with handwritten labels on a wooden counter beside copper pots and a window
Small jars, tight lids, dated in marker. Six months, not three years.

Two habits worth building. Buy whole spice wherever you can and grind it yourself, and write the date on the jar. Ground spice is at its best for about six months, not three years. Those two changes will do more for your cooking than any new pan.

The workhorse

Texas Sunrise Shake (Everyday House Blend)

Golden as a Texas sunrise. Sweet paprika, garlic, and garden herbs that go on chicken, fish, vegetables, beans, and eggs.

Yield: About ½ cup

Ingredients

Method: Whisk everything together until the color is even. Store airtight up to 6 months.

How much to use: 1 to 2 teaspoons per pound of chicken, fish, or vegetables. About 1 tablespoon for a pot of beans.

Suggested uses: Roast chicken, grilled or roasted vegetables, fish, a pot of beans, scrambled or fried eggs.

For chicken

Henhouse Gold (Chicken Seasoning)

A farmhouse favorite. Garlic-forward and gently smoky, it paints chicken a beautiful golden brown.

Yield: About ½ cup

Ingredients

Method: Whisk everything together until the color is even. Store airtight up to 6 months.

How much to use: 1 to 2 tablespoons seasons a whole chicken.

Suggested uses: Rub on roasted or grilled chicken, spatchcocked chicken (under or over the skin), a dry rub before grilling or searing, roasted vegetables, popcorn seasoning, scrambled eggs.

Try it in: Roast Chicken and Potatoes with Lemon and Herbs →

For fish

Gulf Coast Harbor Blend (Seafood Seasoning)

Bright, fresh, and a little bit sunny. Toasting the seeds wakes them up, and dill keeps every bite light.

Yield: About ⅓ cup

Ingredients

  • 2 tablespoons organic coriander seed, toasted and ground
  • 1 tablespoon organic fennel seed, toasted and ground
  • 1 tablespoon organic dried dill
  • 2 teaspoons organic granulated onion
  • 1 teaspoon organic white pepper

Method: Whisk everything together until the color is even. Store airtight up to 6 months.

How much to use: About 1 teaspoon per 6-ounce fillet.

Suggested uses: Wild caught salmon and other fish, shrimp, roasted potatoes, cucumber salad.

For roasting

Gold Rush Rub (Root Vegetable Rub)

Warm, golden, and a little exotic. Turmeric and cumin with ginger and a touch of cardamom make root vegetables shine.

Yield: About ⅓ cup

Ingredients

Method: Whisk everything together until the color is even. Store airtight up to 6 months.

How much to use: 1 to 2 teaspoons per pound of root vegetables, tossed with olive oil and a pinch of salt.

Suggested uses: Carrots, parsnips, sweet potatoes, potatoes, cauliflower, roasted chickpeas, chicken thighs.

For slow cooking

Fireside Pot Spice (Braising Blend)

Made for slow cooking on cold days. Paprika and cumin build the base, and cinnamon and clove wrap it all in warmth.

Yield: About ⅓ cup

Ingredients

Method: Whisk everything together until the color is even. Store airtight up to 6 months.

How much to use: About 1 tablespoon per 2 pounds of meat, or for a large pot of stew or beans.

Suggested uses: Braised chicken thighs, lamb, grass-fed beef stew, a pot of beans, root vegetable stew.

For the sweet side

Warm Custard Spice (Sweet Baking Blend)

Baked custards, poached fruit, anything with milk and eggs and not much sugar. Grate the nutmeg fresh and you will taste the difference immediately.

Yield: About 3 tablespoons

Ingredients

Method: Whisk everything together until the color is even. Store airtight up to 6 months.

How much to use: ½ to 1 teaspoon per recipe.

Suggested uses: Custards, poached fruit, baked apples, oats, homemade granola.

For apples and fall baking

Apple Ember Kiss Blend (Apple Pie Spice)

Ceylon cinnamon, vanilla bean, and four warm spices. Made for apples, and wonderful on just about everything sweet.

Yield: About ⅓ cup

Ingredients

Method: Use dry spoons and level all spices, then whisk or shake in a sealed jar until the vanilla flecks are evenly distributed. Store airtight up to 6 months.

How much to use: About 1½ tablespoons for a full 9-inch pie’s worth of apples (6 to 8 apples).

Pro tip: As it bakes, the vanilla softens the edge of the cinnamon and pulls the warm spices together.

Suggested uses: On organic sprouted rolled oats or fruit, stirred into yogurt, over roasted sweet potatoes, squash, or pears, a chicken-apple skillet, smoothies, granola.

Try it in: Deconstructed Apple Pie Bowl →

The method, once, for all of them

  1. Toast the organic whole seeds. Dry pan, medium heat, keep them moving until you can smell them. Usually 60 to 90 seconds. Coriander, cumin, fennel, and cardamom all improve dramatically. Ground spices like turmeric and paprika do not get toasted; they burn. If you buy cumin or cardamom whole, toast and grind them too.
  2. Cool completely. Grinding warm spice makes it clump.
  3. Grind. A dedicated electric grinder is easiest. A mortar and pestle works and gives you a coarser, more interesting texture.
  4. Mix and jar. Small glass jar, tight lid, out of direct light. Never above the stove, which is the warmest and worst spot in the kitchen.
  5. Date it. A piece of tape and a marker. Aim to finish a jar within six months.
For your shelf

Free printable jar labels

One label for each blend, with the name and a line to write the date. Sign up and download them right away.

Never sold. Unsubscribe any time.

What to buy

Spice quality varies more than almost any other ingredient category, and the difference between a good jar of paprika and a supermarket one is not subtle. I keep a running list of the brands and tools I buy for my own kitchen.

See what I use